Newport Bay vs Hotel New York: which is worth the extra cost?
Two of the premium Disney hotels. Both get you a lakeside setting and the closest walk to the parks. Here is when each one is worth the price.
Disney Newport Bay Club vs Disney Hotel New York – The Art of Marvel: who takes each round
Cheapest
Newport Bay
Closest to park
Hotel New York
Best for Marvel fans
Hotel New York
Best for relaxed family stays
Newport Bay
Best food
Hotel New York
Best overall value
Newport Bay
Full comparison table
| Category | Disney Newport Bay Club | Disney Hotel New York – The Art of Marvel | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical price (family of 4, 4 nights, term time) | £1,580 with tickets | £1,940 with tickets | Disney Newport Bay Club |
| Accommodation | New England nautical theme, refurbished rooms | Marvel themed, modern boutique style | Tie |
| Food | Cape Cod buffet, Yacht Club for grown ups | Manhattan Restaurant, top tier on site dining | Disney Hotel New York – The Art of Marvel |
| Activities (in hotel) | Indoor pool, lakeside walks | Indoor pool, Marvel character art trail, gallery | Disney Hotel New York – The Art of Marvel |
| Travel to park | 12 to 15 minute lakeside walk | 8 to 10 minute walk, closest of all the lakeside hotels | Disney Hotel New York – The Art of Marvel |
| Flexibility (rooms for 5 or 6) | Limited family rooms for 5 | Empire State Club rooms for 4 to 5 | Disney Newport Bay Club |
| Overall family value | More magic per £ for the average family | Higher price but you feel it in the rooms | Disney Newport Bay Club |
Which one wins for which family?
Best for young children
Newport Bay
Calmer atmosphere, easier rooms, plenty of pool time after park days.
Best for teenagers
Hotel New York
Marvel theming, modern rooms and a buzz teenagers actually rate.
Best budget option (of the two)
Newport Bay
Same premium location for several hundred pounds less.
Best premium option
Hotel New York Empire State Club
Lounge access, upgraded breakfast, the closest you get to a five star Disney experience in Paris.
Hidden costs most families miss
The extras that quietly add hundreds to the final bill.
Half board upgrade
Both hotels offer pricey half board. Hotel New York's premium dining makes the upgrade more justified there than at Newport Bay.
Parking
€20 per night at both hotels. Often forgotten when comparing to Santa Fe.
Empire State Club
Sounds magical but adds £80 to £150 per night. Worth it for a couple's anniversary, less so with three children.
Premier Access
Hotel benefits do not include skip the queue for the biggest rides. Budget £15 to £30 per ride per person if you want it.
Tourist tax
Around €4 per adult per night collected at check out.
What we would actually book
Newport Bay is the smarter family pick nine times out of ten. You get the lakeside setting, the short walk to the park, comfortable rooms and a calm post park atmosphere for £200 to £400 less than Hotel New York.
Hotel New York earns its premium if Marvel is a genuine love in your family or you want the most modern hotel in the resort. The food, the art trail and the proximity to the parks are all real and lovely.
If you cannot decide, the rule of thumb is simple. Children under 8 with no Marvel obsession go to Newport Bay. Children 8 and over who know their MCU go to Hotel New York. The savings report can settle it for your exact dates.
Frequently asked
Which is more expensive, Newport Bay or Hotel New York?
Hotel New York Art of Marvel is the premium pick and runs £200 to £600 more for a family of four for 4 nights. Newport Bay sits in the upper middle tier.
Is Hotel New York worth the extra over Newport Bay?
If you have Marvel obsessed kids and value modern rooms with strong styling, yes. For most other families, Newport Bay's lakeside setting and more relaxed feel are the better fit.
Do both include Extra Magic Time?
Yes, both are on site Disney hotels with the full 30 minute Extra Magic Time access and park tickets bundled with stays.
Which is closer to the parks?
Newport Bay is roughly a 12 to 15 minute lakeside walk. Hotel New York is the closest of the two, around 8 to 10 minutes.
Still unsure?
We'll compare your options properly and help you avoid overpaying. £19, one off, no commission, most reports the same day.